Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Hustler's Tavern is a famous historic site in Lewiston, NY named after the original owner, 

Catherine Hustler. 

Catherine Hustler's Tavern was one of the only buildings left standing when Lewiston was burned to the ground in 1813 by the British Soldiers.

The story goes that the American soldiers had raided a British commissary and brought Catherine some fowl which she roasted for the feast. She decorated all the bottles and jars in the tavern with tail feathers. One guest called for a glass of the cocktail, and hence, the name was born.


Famous for our Detroit Style Pizza and hand-crafted "cocktails!"

Located 800 Center Street, Lewiston, NY

Check out our menu!

View Menu

Book Your Reservations Today!

Call 716-246-2392

Book Now

Follow Us On Instagram and Facebook!